Skip to content
Fair Housing Compliance in Tenant Screening
Back to Blog
Landlord Tips

Fair Housing Compliance in Tenant Screening

Christian FernandezMarch 1, 2025

While screening tenants, it's vital to comply with the Fair Housing Act (FHA), which prohibits discrimination based on race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status, or disability. Massachusetts adds its own, longer list of protected classes under state law, covered next, and the Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination enforces it.

Massachusetts goes further than the federal list. Under M.G.L. c.151B §4, a landlord in Massachusetts may not refuse, steer, or set different terms because of race, color, religious creed, national origin, ancestry, sex, gender identity, sexual orientation, age, marital status, veteran or military status, genetic information, disability, children, or because the applicant receives public assistance or a housing subsidy such as a Section 8 voucher. Refusing a voucher holder, or advertising “no Section 8,” is a frequent basis for complaints and for Attorney General enforcement against small landlords and the brokers who list for them. Criminal history is not a protected class in housing, but how you may use a CORI report is separately regulated, so treat it as a screening criterion you apply consistently, not a blanket bar.

The exemptions are narrow, and none of them covers advertising. Under c.151B §4(6)–(7), most of the state rules do not apply when an owner rents out the single other unit of a two-family they live in. That exemption does not reach the public-assistance and voucher rule in §4(10), which has no owner-occupant carve-out. The familial-status (children) rule in §4(11) adds two carve-outs of its own: a building of three or fewer apartments where one unit is occupied by an elderly person (65 or over) or an infirm person for whom the presence of children would be a hardship, and an owner's temporary lease of the home they ordinarily occupy as their principal residence. The federal “Mrs. Murphy” exemption in 42 U.S.C. §3603(b) (owner-occupied buildings of four or fewer units, or a single-family house rented without a broker) is broader on paper but does not override Massachusetts law, and the moment a broker or agent is involved the federal single-family exemption is gone. Discriminatory notices and ads are prohibited for everyone under §4(7B) and 42 U.S.C. §3604(c), exemption or not.

Let's get right into how to ensure compliance with Massachusetts tenant fair housing laws. Here are some tips to avoid discrimination claims:

1Consistent Screening Criteria

Apply the same screening criteria to all applicants. Document your process and ensure every applicant goes through the same steps.

2Objective Criteria

Base your decisions on objective criteria such as income, credit history, and rental history. Avoid subjective judgments that could be perceived as discriminatory. In Massachusetts, those criteria may not exclude voucher holders: you cannot require employment-based income, and any income standard has to take the amount of the voucher into account. See the state's source-of-income discrimination FAQ.

3Clear Communication

Communicate your screening criteria clearly in your rental listings and during interactions with potential tenants. This transparency helps set expectations and reduces misunderstandings.

4Documentation

Keep thorough records of all communications, applications, and the reasons for acceptance or denial of each applicant. This documentation can protect you if an applicant claims discrimination.

5Training

Ensure that anyone involved in the tenant selection process is trained in fair housing laws and understands the importance of compliance.

A consistent, transparent, and documented approach is key to both selecting quality tenants and protecting yourself from legal issues.

By adhering to these guidelines, landlords can effectively screen tenants while avoiding discrimination claims. Remember, a consistent, transparent, and documented approach is key to both selecting quality tenants and protecting yourself from legal issues. This not only ensures compliance with the law but also fosters a fair and inclusive rental market.

Avoiding discrimination claims is crucial for maintaining the integrity and reputation of your rental business. By implementing these strategies, landlords can attract and retain quality tenants while upholding fair housing practices.

If you're interested in learning more about Massachusetts tenant fair housing, contact a Zenith Residential Properties agent today!

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Fair Housing Act and how does it apply in Massachusetts?

The federal Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination in housing based on race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status, or disability. Massachusetts adds additional protections at the state level. The law applies to nearly all rental and sale transactions, including most small landlords.

How can landlords avoid fair housing discrimination claims in Massachusetts?

Apply consistent screening criteria to every applicant, base decisions on objective factors (income that counts any voucher, credit history, rental history), communicate criteria clearly in your listing and during showings, document the screening process for every applicant, and train anyone involved in tenant selection on fair housing law.

What objective criteria can landlords use to screen tenants?

Acceptable objective criteria include verifiable income, credit history, rental history, and references from prior landlords, applied uniformly to every applicant and documented. In Massachusetts, screening criteria may not exclude voucher holders: you cannot require employment-based income, and any income standard (such as a multiple of the monthly rent) has to take the amount of the voucher into account. Avoid subjective judgments that could be perceived as discriminatory.

Why is documentation important when screening tenants?

Thorough records of all communications, applications, and the specific reasons for acceptance or denial of each applicant are your best protection if a fair housing claim is filed. Documentation demonstrates that decisions were based on consistent, objective criteria — not protected characteristics.

Does fair housing law apply to small landlords in Massachusetts?

Yes, in nearly all cases. The one broad state exemption is renting out the other unit of a two-family you live in, and it does not cover the voucher rule: refusing a renter because of a housing subsidy is unlawful there too. The familial-status rule adds narrow carve-outs for buildings of three or fewer apartments with an elderly (65+) or infirm resident, and for a temporary lease of your own principal residence. The federal owner-occupied four-unit exemption does not override Massachusetts law, discriminatory advertising is never exempt, and listing with a broker removes the federal single-family exemption. When in doubt, assume the law applies and comply.

Should landlords communicate screening criteria in rental listings?

Yes. Stating your objective screening criteria (for example an income standard that counts a voucher toward the rent, and rental history) in your rental listing sets clear expectations, reduces wasted applications, and demonstrates transparency. It also reinforces that decisions are criteria-based, not arbitrary.

Ready to Optimize Your Real Estate Asset?

Get clarity on your next real estate move with a complimentary asset review from our team.

Talk with a Zenith Advisor